Let us stipulate the following:
- The Chinese government is not monolithic, and thus does not hold a single unified viewpoint on anything;
- Opinions expressed in the media are often trial balloons; and
- State media have, in the past, often represented minority points-of-view in the party.
All the above said, it is also true that Xi is wont to visit key media outlets – including The Global Times – to underscore that it is the duty of all media “love the party, protect the party, and closely align with the party leadership in thought, politics and action.” It is apparent to anyone watching the media in China – and that’s a lot of what we have to do in my business – that whatever tolerance there might have been for a degree of editorial heterodoxy is evaporating fast, if it has not already turned to fog.
Thus the assertion that The Global Times is offering opinions at odds with the thinking in Zhongnanhai to be far less credible today than three years ago. Lacking evidence to the contrary, we can only believe that the GT speaks with the voice and support of the highest party leaders.